How to Welcome New Members So They Actually Come Back
Most newcomers decide whether they belong within their first visit. Here's a step-by-step checklist for welcoming new members so they stay.
6 min read

Most groups don't lose new members because of anything dramatic. They lose them in the first fifteen minutes of the first visit, when a nervous newcomer stands by the door holding a drink, watching a circle of old friends laugh at an inside joke, and quietly decides, "This isn't for me."
Nobody was rude. Nobody did anything wrong. And that's exactly the problem. Knowing how to welcome new members is a skill most groups never think about, because the regulars already feel at home. They've forgotten what it's like to walk in cold.
This guide is for organisers, hosts and regular members who want newcomers to stick. It's laid out as a timeline: before the first visit, during it, and in the days after.
Why the first visit matters so much
Think about your own first time at a book club, a church, a running group or a new office. You were probably scanning for clues. Do people talk to strangers here? Is there a clique I'll never break into? Will anyone notice if I don't come back?
Psychologists who study belonging talk about a sense of community: the feeling that you're a member, that you matter to the group, and that the group matters to you. A newcomer can't feel all of that on day one. But they can get a strong hint of whether it's possible, and that hint shapes whether they return.
People don't come back to a group. They come back to the person who made them feel seen.
Before they arrive: set the stage
A good welcome starts before anyone walks through the door.
Make the basics easy to find
Have one clear, friendly "start here" message or page that answers:
- what the group is about, in one or two sentences;
- when and where you meet;
- what happens at a typical meetup;
- what to bring, if anything;
- who to look for when you arrive.
Nothing turns people away faster than having to ask five questions just to show up.
Reach out personally
If someone joins your group chat or community page, a short, personal message beats any automated welcome:
"Hey Chiamaka, welcome! We're meeting Saturday at 4pm at the usual spot. I'll be wearing a yellow cap, come find me and I'll introduce you around."
That single message removes the biggest fear newcomers have: walking in and not knowing who to talk to.
Assign a buddy
For groups that meet in person, give each newcomer a "buddy", a friendly regular who looks out for them for their first visit or two. It doesn't need to be formal. "Femi, there's a new person coming Saturday, could you keep an eye out for her?" is enough.
The first fifteen minutes: the make-or-break window
This is where it counts.
- Greet them at the door, by name if you can. "You must be Chiamaka! So glad you came."
- Introduce them to two or three people, with a hook. "This is Tunde, he's also new to Lekki" or "Ama loves the same author you mentioned."
- Explain what's about to happen. "We usually chat for twenty minutes, then start the discussion around 4:30."
- Give them something to do. Hand them the snack tray, ask them to help set up chairs, or invite them to pick the next song. A small job makes people feel part of things instead of like guests.
- Check in mid-way. A quick "How are you finding it?" lets them know someone's paying attention.
Watch out for the inside-joke wall
Regulars often don't notice how much they talk in shorthand. "Remember when Kunle fell in the pool?" is hilarious to six people and alienating to the seventh. If an inside joke comes up, take three seconds to explain it: "Long story, Kunle once fell into a pool at a birthday. We'll never let him forget it." Now the newcomer is in on it.
Mix up the seating and the circles
Tight circles are cosy for members and impenetrable for newcomers. Leave gaps. Physically open up a circle when you see someone hovering. If there's a game or activity, put newcomers on teams with regulars instead of letting them cluster with other new faces.
Icebreakers can help here, as long as they're light. A round of Two Truths and a Lie or a quick Would You Rather question does wonders. Our list of icebreaker questions for groups has plenty that won't make anyone cringe.
At the end: make the next step obvious
Don't let the first visit end with a vague wave goodbye.
- Tell them when the next meetup is. "Same time next month, and there's a smaller hangout on the 12th if you're free."
- Invite them personally. "I really hope you come back. It was great having you."
- Add them to the right channel, whether that's the group chat, community page or mailing list, if they haven't been added yet.
The 48 hours after: the follow-up most groups skip
This is where great groups separate themselves from good ones. Within a day or two, send a short message:
- "Thanks for coming on Saturday! Hope it wasn't too overwhelming meeting everyone at once."
- "Ama said she loved chatting with you about that book. You two should connect."
- "Here's the link to the next event. Hope to see you there."
That tiny follow-up turns a nice afternoon into the start of something. It tells the newcomer, "We noticed you. We'd like you back."
If your group runs as a Kindred community, posting the next event right away means newcomers can tap to say they're going together with someone they met, which is a lovely low-pressure way to make the second visit feel less lonely.
The first three months: from newcomer to regular
A person usually needs a few visits before they feel like they belong. Help that along:
- Remember things about them. Their job, their dog's name, the exam they were nervous about.
- Give them a small role by the third or fourth visit, like picking a book, hosting a game round or bringing snacks.
- Invite them to smaller gatherings. Big meetups are good for meeting people; small ones are where friendships form.
- Ask for their opinion. "You're new, so you've got fresh eyes. What would make this group better?" Newcomers often spot problems regulars have stopped seeing.
A quick checklist to welcome new members
Print it, pin it or paste it in your organisers' chat:
- Clear "start here" info is easy to find.
- Each newcomer gets a personal welcome message.
- A buddy is assigned for the first visit.
- Someone greets them at the door.
- They're introduced to at least two people with a hook.
- Inside jokes get a quick explanation.
- They know when the next event is before they leave.
- A follow-up message goes out within 48 hours.
- By their third visit, they've been offered a small role.
Over to you
At your next meetup, make it your personal mission to find the newest person in the room and introduce them to two people. That's all. If everyone in your group did that once, nobody would ever stand alone by the door again.
If you're the newcomer instead, our guide to joining a group where everyone already knows each other is for you. Organisers might also like community organiser burnout for tips on sharing the work of welcoming. For more on making strangers into friends, browse our making friends section, and see how Kindred handles groups on the how it works page.