Stuck in a Situationship? How to Get Clarity Kindly
Not dating, not just friends, definitely not nothing. If you're in a situationship and want answers, here's how to ask for clarity without losing yourself.
6 min read

It's 11:47pm. Your phone lights up with "wyd". You know exactly what this means and also have no idea what this means.
You've been "talking" for five months. You've met their friends once, by accident. You spent a lovely Sunday together cooking egusi, and then they didn't text for six days. You're not exclusive, but you'd be gutted if they were seeing someone else. You don't know what to call it, so you don't call it anything.
Welcome to the situationship. If you want out of the fog, this is a step-by-step guide to getting clarity, kindly, without turning into someone you don't recognise.
What a situationship actually is
A situationship is a romantic or sexual connection without a clear label or commitment. It's more than friendship, less than a relationship, and the defining feature is ambiguity. Nobody's quite sure what the rules are, and usually nobody's asked.
Situationships aren't automatically bad. Sometimes both people genuinely want something casual and are happy with it. The trouble starts when one person wants more and is too scared to say so, or when the vagueness becomes a way to avoid responsibility.
Some signs you're in one:
- Plans are last-minute and rarely more than a few days ahead.
- You haven't met their close friends or family, or only by chance.
- You avoid talking about the future, even next month.
- You feel anxious more often than happy.
- You're not sure if you're allowed to be upset about things.
If you need a decoder ring to understand someone's feelings for you, the answer is usually less than you hoped for.
How to get clarity in a situationship, step by step
Six steps, in order. Skip the first two and the conversation tends to go sideways.
Step 1: Get clear with yourself first
Before you ask them what this is, ask yourself what you want it to be. This sounds obvious, but many people walk into "the talk" hoping the other person will define things for them.
Spend ten minutes with these questions:
- If they said "let's be exclusive" tomorrow, would I feel relief or panic?
- If they said "I just want to keep things casual", could I genuinely be okay with that?
- Am I staying because I like them, or because I like the possibility of them?
- How do I feel most days in this: calm, excited, anxious, small?
- What do I want my love life to look like a year from now?
Write the answers down. Your future self, mid-conversation and slightly flustered, will thank you.
Step 2: Notice the pattern, not the highlights
Situationships run on highlight reels. That perfect Sunday. That 2am voice note. Those moments are real, but so are the six silent days.
Try a simple exercise: for two weeks, note how you feel each day about this connection, in one word. At the end, look at the list. If it's mostly "anxious", "waiting" and "confused", that's information, however magical the good days were.
Some people find attachment theory helpful here. The idea, rooted in research by psychologists like John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth, is that early relationships shape how we connect as adults, which is why some of us chase reassurance and others pull away when things get close. You can read an overview of attachment theory if you're curious. It isn't a diagnosis, but it can explain why ambiguity hits some people much harder than others.
Step 3: Pick the right moment
Timing matters. Don't have the "what are we?" talk:
- Over text at midnight after they've left you on read.
- In front of other people.
- Right after an argument or when either of you has been drinking.
- When you're already halfway out the door.
Do have it:
- In person or on a call, when you're both calm.
- Somewhere neutral and private enough to speak honestly, a walk is perfect.
- When you have time to actually talk afterwards.
Step 4: Say it plainly, using "I"
You don't need a speech. You need a few honest sentences. Here are scripts you can adapt:
If you want more: "I really enjoy spending time with you, and I've realised I want something more committed. I'd love to know where you're at with this."
If you're unsure what they want: "I've noticed we've never really talked about what this is. I'm not trying to pressure you, I'd just like us both to be on the same page. How do you see us?"
If you're ready to leave if nothing changes: "I like you a lot, but the uncertainty isn't working for me any more. I'm looking for something clear and committed. If that's not where you are, I understand, and I think we should stop here."
Notice what these have in common: they say what you feel and what you want. They don't accuse ("you're using me"), and they don't beg ("please just tell me you care"). Clarity is calm.
Step 5: Listen to the answer you get, not the one you wanted
This is the hardest step. People often give clear answers that we then reinterpret.
- "I'm not looking for anything serious right now" usually means exactly that. Not "with you, yet". Not "until I've sorted my career". Take it at face value.
- "I don't like labels" can be genuine, but ask what it means in practice. Are they seeing other people? Will they introduce you to friends? Labels matter less than behaviour.
- "Let's see where it goes" is fine on date three. At month seven, it's a stall.
- "Yes, I want that too" is wonderful, and then you watch whether their actions change to match.
If they need time to think, that's reasonable. Agree on a timeframe. "Of course. Shall we talk again next weekend?" keeps it from drifting back into fog.
Step 6: Act on what you learn
If you both want commitment.
Lovely. Talk about what that looks like: exclusivity, meeting friends, how often you'll see each other. Then start the bigger values conversations you might have been avoiding.
If you want different things.
You have two choices: accept the casual setup honestly, with your eyes open, or leave. Staying while secretly hoping they'll change usually hurts more over time.
Leaving can sound like: "Thank you for being honest. I need something different, so I'm going to step back. I'm glad we talked." Then actually step back. Mute, archive, give yourself space. Our guide on handling rejection gracefully has more on getting through the sting.
If they dodge the question entirely.
That's an answer too. Someone who can't give you a straight response after months isn't offering what you need.
How to avoid the next situationship
You can't prevent every grey area, but you can make them rarer:
- Say what you want early. Not on the first message, but within the first few dates. "I'm looking for something serious eventually" is a perfectly normal thing to say.
- Watch actions over words. Consistent effort beats charming texts.
- Keep a full life. Friends, hobbies and community make you less likely to cling to crumbs. Our wellbeing posts talk about building that kind of fullness.
- Choose people who are clear about their intentions. One reason Kindred's Discover explains why you match on a values profile is so you start with clarity instead of guesswork. Dating is an optional part of it, and you decide what you're open to. You can see how it works on the how it works page.
For a fuller approach to all this, read our guide to dating with intention.
Your next small step
Don't wait for the perfect moment. Write down your answer to one question tonight: "What do I want this to be?"
Then, within the next week, have one honest conversation using the scripts above. Calmly, kindly, using "I".
Whatever the answer, you'll know where you stand, and knowing is so much lighter than wondering. What would you say if you weren't scared of the answer?