How Men Make Close Friends (Beyond Banter and Football)
Two guys can share a five-a-side pitch for ten years and still not know each other's middle names. Here's how men make close friends that go deeper than banter.
7 min read

Two men can play five-a-side together every Thursday for ten years, share a thousand goal celebrations and a hundred arguments about offside, and still not know whether the other one has a sister. That's not a joke. That's a lot of guys you know. Maybe it's you.
This post is about how men make close friends as adults, the kind of friend you can call when the job goes sideways or the marriage gets heavy, not just when Arsenal bottles the title again. Plenty of men have mates. Fewer have someone they'd actually tell the hard stuff to. The gap between those two things is smaller than it looks, and it mostly closes with a few small, slightly brave moves.
Let's clear out the myths first, because they're doing a lot of quiet damage.
Myth 1: "Men just don't need close friends like women do"
This one gets repeated so often it sounds like science. It isn't. Men are people, and people need connection. The long-running Harvard Study of Adult Development, which has followed participants for decades, keeps pointing in the same direction: the quality of our relationships is tied up with how well we live and age. You can read about the work on the study's own site.
What is true is that many men were raised to show friendship differently. Turning up to help you move house. Lending you the drill and never asking for it back. Roasting you at your wedding. Those things count. But if they're the only currency, a man can be surrounded by people and still feel like nobody really knows him.
So the goal isn't to make male friendship look like a different kind of friendship. It's to add one more layer on top of what already works.
Myth 2: "If we were meant to be close, it would happen naturally"
At school it did happen naturally, because you were forced into the same room five days a week. Adult life removes the forced room. Work, family, traffic and that one more episode at night eat the hours that friendship used to get for free.
Closeness now needs a container. For a lot of men, the easiest container is a regular thing with a built-in activity:
- a weekly game of football, basketball or squash;
- a monthly barbecue or suya-and-pepper-soup night at someone's place;
- a standing Saturday morning run or walk;
- an online game session with the same three guys every Sunday;
- a fix-it club, where someone's car, bike or generator is the excuse.
That last one isn't as random as it sounds. The Men's Shed movement, which started in Australia, is built on exactly this idea: men gathering to work on practical projects, with conversation happening around the work instead of being the point of it.
Men often talk best shoulder to shoulder, not face to face. Give the hands a job and the mouth relaxes.
Myth 3: "Talking about feelings will make it weird"
It might, if you go from zero to a forty-minute monologue about your childhood over a plate of asun. Nobody's asking for that.
Depth builds in small steps. Think of it as turning the dial one notch at a time:
- Notch one: facts. "Work's been mad this month."
- Notch two: a small opinion. "Honestly, I don't think I want to stay there another year."
- Notch three: a feeling. "It's been stressing me more than I let on."
- Notch four: a need. "Can I run something past you? I need a second brain on this."
Most guys stall at notch one forever. If you go to notch two and your friend matches you, go to three next time. If he jokes it off, that's fine too. Jokes are often how men check the water temperature before getting in. Leave the door open with something like, "Lol, seriously though, if you ever want to talk about it, I'm around."
Here are a few lines that work without sounding like a therapy session:
- "What's actually going on with you these days? Not the work answer."
- "You good? You've been quiet in the chat."
- "I've been thinking about something and you're the guy I'd ask."
- "That sounds rough, man. What's the worst part?"
Notice that last one. A follow-up question is the most underrated friendship move on earth. It tells the other person you heard them and you're not in a hurry to change the subject back to the match.
Myth 4: "It's too late, everyone already has their guys"
This is the one that keeps men in their thirties, forties and fifties stuck. You look around and assume everyone else has a tight crew from university, and you'd be gate-crashing.
In reality, lots of men are in the same boat and quietly hoping someone else makes the first move. Crews drift. People move to Ottawa or Abuja or Manchester. Some friends get married and vanish into school runs. If anything, many men are looking for a fresh guy to add.
Practical ways in:
- Say yes to the second invite. The first time you go to the colleague's barbecue, you're a guest. The second time, you're a regular. Being a regular is where friendship starts.
- Be the guy who organises one thing. It doesn't have to be grand. "Five-a-side Saturday, 7am, who's in?" in a group chat can quietly create a whole circle.
- Join something with a schedule. A club, a league, a church men's fellowship, a cycling group. Repetition is your friend. We wrote more about this in how long it takes to make a friend.
- Try a values-matched intro. On Kindred, Discover can introduce you to a few people a day based on what you actually care about, and you can keep it firmly in the friends lane. Dating is optional, not the default.
Myth 5: "Asking a guy to hang out one-on-one is awkward"
It's only awkward if you make it sound like a proposal. Make it about a thing, and keep it light:
- "I'm trying that new barber on Saturday, then getting food after. Want to come?"
- "I've got two tickets to the match. You free?"
- "I'm watching the fight at mine Friday. Pull up."
- "Need help choosing a laptop. You know this stuff better than me. Lunch on me?"
The last one works because asking for help is a surprisingly strong friendship move. People tend to like those they've done a favour for. It also gives the other guy a clear role, which takes the pressure off.
If you want a gentle on-ramp, games help too. A few rounds of Ludo, Okada Race or World & Africa Trivia in a live room with a guy you've just met is low-stakes, mildly competitive and gives you something to trash-talk about later. Trash talk is, after all, a love language in many male friendships. For more on asking without overthinking, see our guide to friend dates.
Myth 6: "Real men handle things alone"
This one isn't just unhelpful. It can be dangerous. When things get really heavy, carrying them alone makes everything harder. A close friend is not a replacement for professional help, but he can be the person who notices you're not okay and nudges you to get it.
If you're the one struggling, the NHS has good, practical starting points through Every Mind Matters, and talking to a doctor or a counsellor is a sign of strength, not the opposite. If you're worried about a friend, you don't need perfect words. "I've noticed you've been off lately, and I care about you. What's going on?" is plenty.
A four-week plan: how men make close friends from mates
If you want something concrete, try this with one or two guys you already like:
- Week 1: Send a message that isn't logistics. A memory, a meme that's specifically for him, or "Random, but how's your dad doing?"
- Week 2: Suggest one activity, just the two or three of you. Gym, food, a game, fixing something.
- Week 3: During that hangout, go one notch deeper than usual. Share one real thing that's going on with you.
- Week 4: Follow up on something he told you. "Did you end up talking to your boss?" This is where friendship turns from casual into close.
Then repeat. Close friends are made from dozens of small reps, the same way a good first touch is.
Here's your challenge for this week: pick one guy you've known for ages but only really talk to about football, work or politics. Send him one message that asks about him. Then see what happens when you stop waiting for friendship to happen on its own. And if you're the one who usually plans, our piece on being the friend who plans will keep you going without burning out. You can browse more ideas in our wellbeing section too.